Pistol Smith Forum banner
1 - 20 of 23 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
827 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
As most of you know I really love my STAR UltraStar and think it's about the best 9mm ever made. I just finished doing a comparison of my UltraStar, my SiGPro 2009 and my HS2K. I thought some of you might enjoy seeing the comparison.

First, what is common to all of them?
  • all have Polymer Frames [/*:m:j5jxkk22]
  • similar grip angles [/*:m:j5jxkk22]
  • all are 9mm [/*:m:j5jxkk22]
  • absolutely reliable [/*:m:j5jxkk22]
  • more accurate than I am [/*:m:j5jxkk22]
  • good looking (purely subjective and YMMV) [/*:m:j5jxkk22]

What is different?
  • The STAR is the smallest of the three [/*:m:j5jxkk22]
  • SiGPro and HS2K are almost exactly the same size [/*:m:j5jxkk22]
  • each has a different manual of arms [/*:m:j5jxkk22]
  • takedown procedures are different [/*:m:j5jxkk22]
  • the weights are slightly different, SiGPro = 28 oz, STAR = 27oz & HS2000 = 23 oz[/*:m:j5jxkk22]

The review.

All of the pistols shoot well and so far have been absolutely reliable. I'd trust anyone of them at any time. The standard magazine for the HS2K and the SiGPro are ten rounds staggered stack. The STAR is a 9 round single stack.

Here is my HS2K and a SiGPro.


The STAR and a SiGPro.


And my STAR on top of my HS2K.


One thing that needs to be considered when talking about second shots and return to POA is bore axis. Of the three, the STAR has the lowest , the HS2K is about half the barrel diameter higher and the SiGPro slightly over 1/2 diameter.

STAR vs. HS2K.


STAR vs. SiGPro.


Of the three, the STAR has the easiest takedown. There is a small pin that gets pushed out right to left. Then the slide simply is slipped off. In this picture it is the small indented pin over the trigger area.


The HS2K has a lever that is raised to disassemble. Still relatively easy but not as nice as on the STAR. In this photo you can see the lever right above the front trigger guard. There is a cut out near the muzzle that allows the lever to pivot up.


The SiGPro is a bitch to take down. There is no lock back as on the STAR or HS2K to help position it. Instead you hold the slide back while pushing the slide lock lever out from right to left. Again, on reassembly you have to hold the slide manually and get everything aligned. It's not too bad but it certainly isn't up to the standards of either the HS2K or the STAR. In this picture you can see the long slide lock lever on the left side of the 2009 (on the top).


The STAR and the HS2K are almost the same width. Since the STAR is a single stack mag that might seem surprising, but the difference is obvious when you look in the magwell. The STAR has a large metal insert and really big cross members so that it doesn’t feel like a polymer pistol at all. I've had several people shoot mine and to be surprised, almost indignant afterwards when I tell them it's a polymer frame pistol.



So there are three polymer-framed pistols. I would rank the STAR as by far the best of the three, then the HS2K and the SiGPro as last. They are all fine pistols, but the STAR just seems to outshine the others. Since it is also by far the least expensive it should be on everyone’s shortlist. The most expensive is the SIGPro, but again, it simply is not as nice as either the HS2K or the UltraStar.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
12 Posts
Nice review-

Many years ago I had a Star Model 28 9mm. It was very well designed and an excellent shooter. Someone stole the gun. Their products are well thought out.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2 Posts
Jim Richardson, what kind of holster do you use for it? I am getting a Ultrastar on Thursday. Also What type of ammo does it like? My favorite 9mm load is the CorBon 115+P.
Thanks for any advice, it is highly appreciated. This is the first gun I've owned in 2 years, money problems caused me to sell my whole collection (which was pretty nice for a guy my age). This Star is 200. used. In the past I had considered getting one of these, a Firestar .45, and Firestar plus 9mm, but each time went with the higher dollar pistol.
Thanks
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
47 Posts
I Agree..............

Just this past week end, I loaded up five 9mm machines
to go for an afternoon of R & R at my local range.

Sig P229, HS2K, XDService 9mm, XDSC9mm, and
the Star UltraStar.

I said R & R, when in total count of rounds downrange,
it numbered over 600 for an afternoon.

When all was said and done, by the way, I had the range
to myself, the UltraStar was the 'star' of the show. The
Star had less perceived recoil, came back on target much
faster and generally gave me the best feeling when I
launched a round downrange. It is the least expensive of
the bunch, but only by a few bucks, as I got the HS2K for
$278 shipped when INTRAC was the importer/distributor.

The XDs of course ran around the $400 mark and the Sig,
well it cost the mostest.

Give that Star a 'star'.

Ed
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1 Posts
I am very, VERY fond of Star pistols, but the Ultrastar was an unfortunate lapse in Bonifacio Echeverria's sensibility.

If you had compared the Ultrastar to some useful gun, its shortcomings would have been manifest.

Just my 2 pesos.

M

P.S. I have two of them. They are nice shooters, but strictly recreational.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
47 Posts
I thought I did compare with a few exceptional modern day
machines, such as Sig P229, HS2K, XDService 9mm, XDSC9mm!

I still give the Star UltaStar a four out of five.

Ed
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
827 Posts
Discussion Starter · #9 ·
I still think the UltraStar is one of my favorite 9s and absolutely my favorite poly of any make.

I am still amazed at how substantial it feels compared to other poly framed guns.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
47 Posts
Years later and my opinion still stands. The UltraStar is still an
amazing machine.

Ed
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1 Posts
I just picked one up in 9mm based on the reviews by Jim and Ed (thanks fellas!). So far I have only put 100 rounds through it, but I have found it to be a great little piece and surprisingly accurate. Now I just need to see what I can do about the dot on the front sight.

 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4 Posts
I just bought one last week, and I've put about 125 rounds through it. No jams, no stovepipes. It failed to lock back a couple times but I think it was getting fouled up. Right off the bat I was impressed by its accuracy compared to my HiPoint C9. Shooting at 15 yards the C9 was grouping about 6 inches (yeah I'm still improving). The Ultrastar was grouped within four inches. It has a wonderful feel in my hand, not too big, not too small. The weight is even, not top heavy like the C9. Yesterday I picked up a box of winchester 147gr JHP rounds to run through it. If it feeds those rounds with no problems thats what I'll carry in it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
708 Posts
If you are going to carry it with the safety on, practice drawing a few minutes every day with an EMPTY gun so pushing the safety off in an emergency will be reflexive.

If you dryfire much, get or make a snap cap. Firining pins may not be easy to get plus you can't use the gun if the firing pin is broken.

Next time start a new thread referencing any pertinent old one(s). A lot of folks don't respond to dead threads.

Welcome Aboard!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,808 Posts
That's going to be really tough.
Star is out of business and there were few parts made for lower production guns like the Ultrastar.

Here's some possible sources:

SARCO bought all the remaining Star parts the American importer had:

Sarco, Inc., Firearms, Firearms Parts and Accessories


This Spanish company was formed by Star employees. They had all the Star parts from the factory, and are said to have plenty of parts for all Star guns:

Calle Sostoa, 2-4
Aptdo. P.O. BOX. 527
20600 Eibar (Spain)
E-mail: [email protected]
Phone: +34 943 20 41 17
Fax : +34 943 12 09 06

Iparguns Manufactura de Armas SL


Bob's Gun Parts bought a lot of Star parts from Interarms when they went out of business:

About Gun Parts! ...Bob's Gun Parts. Top Page Commercial Super Site.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
47 Posts
Star Ultrastar 9mm

The Star Ultrastar 9mm is still in my arsenal and will outperform all my 9mm shooters. I should have concealed carry this machine much more than I have. If you run across one, buy it. You'll enjoy interacting with it.

Happy Thanksgiving to all.
 
1 - 20 of 23 Posts
Top